You are here

Online Poker New York - It's Legal & Legit Real Money Sites Exist!

New York Online Poker for REAL MONEY

Table of Contents
Show   |   Hide

New York online poker is a diverting form of entertainment that many of the state's residents eagerly participate in. You might be under the impression that it's against the law to play the games you love over the internet, but this is not true. Online poker in New York carries no penalties or risks of legal persecution for individual players.

New York has had a very long and tenuous relationship with online poker. On one hand, the online poker landscape was changed forever when the district attorney of Southern New York, Preet Bharara, brought charges against PokerStars, Full Tilt and Absolute Poker/Ultimate Bet in what is now known as “Black Friday.” On the other hand, it was one of the two states that asked the federal government to clarify what exactly constituted illegal gambling in late 2011 and for further clarification as to the definition of the Wire Act. This led to a determination that the Wire Act did not apply to online poker and thus made the provisions of the UIGEA irrelevant for card games played over the internet.

These vacillations on both sides of the issue have caused some sites to not want to offer games to those in New York, but some offshore gambling enterprises have decided that the situation is still good enough to operate within. Below is some quick information on the sites that still offer games to those in New York and the perks you can get for playing on those networks.

What Online Poker Sites Can I Play in New York?

While some operators have elected to exit the New York market, others feel that the population of potential players in the state is too large to ignore. We've checked out all these companies to verify that they're honest, reliable, and competent when it comes to their poker games and software products. Simply read the descriptions below, and when you see a site that looks like it might be right for you, click to sign up to it and begin playing today.

Logo of Ignition

IGNITION CASINO
Highest Traffic


Ignition caters to New Yorkers who are looking for the offshore poker brand with the greatest number of games running at once. They range from micro-stakes NLHE and PLO to high-stakes versions of the same, up to $10/$20, as well as SNGs, lottery-style Jackpots, and MTTs that guarantee more than $1.5 million per week. There's also some action in LHE too for lovers of fixed limit tables. This is an anonymized poker room wherein all screennames are hidden to protect less experienced users.

You can log on and play from a desktop, laptop, iOS platform, Android device, and more because Ignition has downloadable and browser-based software. There's 100% up to $1,000 poker bonus waiting for you and a further $1,500 bonus for casino games.

SB.ag Logo

SPORTSBETTING.AG
Big Bad Beat Jackpot


Sportsbetting.ag's claim to fame is that it sports the largest BBJ promo available to Americans, which is routinely six figures and sometimes reaches into seven. Only certain NLHE tables qualify for the Bad Beat, but there are other forms of poker – like 6+ Hold'em, PLO, and PLO/8 – that are spread too. Tournaments at a range of price points, several types of Windfall lottery poker games, and sit-n-goes round out the selection. You can even compete in weekly leaderboards for cash game and SNG players.

SB.ag poker installs to your Windows or Mac computer, and you can play from Android and iOS smart devices too. The poker welcome bonus is a 100% up to $1,000 match, and there are other deals offered for the sportsbook and casino sections.

Bovada Logo

BOVADA
Poker + Sports


Many NY residents remember playing Bovada immediately after Black Friday, but then it left the scene. Bovada is back for New Yorkers, and it shares a network with Ignition Casino Poker. This means the poker games are the same, but Bovada does have its advantages. The main one is that it boasts a sportsbook, which Ignition lacks, so you can bet on NFL, NCAA, NBA, and MLB contests as well as horses, esports, and a broad menu of other events.

Bovada works on Windows PC, Mac OS, iOS, Android, and a range of other systems. The poker bonus is 100% up to $500 while the casino and sportsbook bonuses are worth $3,000 and $250 respectively. Deposit with Bitcoin to unlock even more favorable specials.

Americas Cardroom Logo

AMERICAS CARDROOM
No Deposit Bonus


ACR hosts the largest poker tourneys that New Yorkers can play online. The weekly Sunday Major is a $215 game with $150,000 guaranteed, and there are frequent opportunities throughout the year to compete in contests with more than $1 million up for grabs. Cash games consist of NLHE, PLO, PLO/8, LO8, and 7 Card Stud. Single table tournaments abound, including lottery-style Jackpots and frequent step SNGs to larger events.

Americas Cardroom has download software for Windows and Mac OS while a limited mobile app runs in your web browser. Our exclusive ACR no deposit bonus code PRB10FREE grants you $10 free. Then when you deposit, you'll get 100% up to $1,000 in bonus funds and a $50 credit.

5Dimes Logo

5DIMES
Free-Free Tourneys


5Dimes is a bit on the smaller side, but what it lacks in volume, it makes up for in rewards. There are a number of fee-free tournaments every day that promise to boost your returns without your having to do anything. Then in the games you play that actually do have a rake, you'll find that it's much less than competing rooms charge, and furthermore, you'll get 50% of the rake back too. Games are on the softer side, thanks to spillover traffic coming from the attached sportsbook and casino.

Almost every computing device on the market is compatible with 5Dimes because the software comes in multiple versions. There's no poker welcome bonus.

Nitrogen Poker Logo

NITROGEN
Browser Software


Nitrogen Poker is perfect if you seek a site that runs in your web browser without anything to download. Cash games are NLHE, Limit Hold'em, PLO, 6+ Holdem, and Crazy Pineapple. There are tourneys too, including freerolls that you can join depending on your playing volume. All cashier functions are done in Bitcoin here for speedy and low-fee transactions.

Nitrogen Poker works on virtually every computing system on the planet. There's no bonus, but you'll get ongoing cashback through the Nitro Rewards program and numerous freerolls.

Logo of SwCPoker

SwCPOKER
Most Poker Variants


At SwC, you'll be able to partake in such delights as OFC, Razz, 2-7 Triple Draw, Badugi, 11-Game Mix, and more. Of course, there are the usual NL Hold'em and PL Omaha tables as well. SwC is descended from the first Bitcoin poker room ever, and this crypto coin remains the only valid way of making deposits and withdrawals. Traffic is pretty light, but the atmosphere is welcoming and cozy.

SwCPoker has recently deployed Mac and mobile software to go along with its Windows client. Though there isn't any first deposit bonus, the Krill Rewards system gives you regular rakeback and freeroll entries.


Selecting a Good Site for Online Poker in New York

Now that we've listed some of the top organizations dealing online poker in New York, it's about time we let you know how to choose where to play. No single room is best in all categories because they each have their own pluses and minuses. It's ultimately up to you to evaluate their features and pick the most attractive option. We realize that this can be difficult, so we've come up with a handful of things for you to consider.

+ If you think it's critical to be able to pick and choose from the largest number of active games, then Ignition, Bovada, and Americas Cardroom have the highest traffic numbers.


+ If you're eager to start playing poker on your mobile device or Mac, then SB.ag, Ignition, Bovada, 5Dimes, and Nitrogen all feature the cross-platform functionality that you seek.


+ If you feel that you deserve a warm welcome, then there's no doubt that Americas Cardroom's $10 no deposit +100% up to $1,000 + $50 deal is among the best.


+ If you enjoy lottery-style SNGs, then Ignition, Bovada, ACR, and Sportsbetting.ag are the four destinations that support these types of games.


+ If you're looking for cash games in less-common poker variants, then SwC is number 1 while Americas Cardroom is a distant second place.


+ If you believe that Bitcoin is the wave of the future, then Nitrogen and SwC permit you to play poker without using fiat money at any point.

Payout Report for Players located in New York State

Black Money Bag

All of the sites we work with allow you to use virtual bitcoins to both fund your accounts and receive your winnings. There are other methods available, like credit cards and money transfer services, but these tend to be a bit cumbersome to work with. Bitcoin permits you to avoid the exorbitant surcharges and lengthy waiting times that sometimes come with traditional payment solutions. If you haven't yet opened your Bitcoin exchange and wallet accounts, then you can learn how to do so here. For general information on payout processing speeds, browse over to our monthly U.S. poker payouts report.

New York's Gambling Laws

Legal Book

The laws pertaining to wagering activities in the State of New York are contained in Article 225 of the Penal Code. After looking over this chapter thoroughly, we conclude that there's no law penalizing individuals who participate in online poker games. You have nothing whatsoever to fear from the law in this matter.

The first part of this section, 225.00, contains important definitions that are referred to in the rest of the gambling laws. As far as what counts as illegal gambling, we read the following:

12. “Unlawful” means not specifically authorized by law.

Well, that's short and sweet. As long as any type of gambling isn't specifically permitted by other statutes in effect within the Empire State, it's illegal. This brings up the subject of what counts as gambling. From the same definitions text:

2. “Gambling.” A person engages in gambling when he stakes or risks something of value upon the outcome of a contest of chance or a future contingent event not under his control or influence, upon an agreement or understanding that he will receive something of value in the event of a certain outcome.

The legislators have helpfully told us what constitutes a “contest of chance”:

1. “Contest of chance” means any contest, game, gaming scheme or gaming device in which the outcome depends in a material degree upon an element of chance, notwithstanding that skill of the contestants may also be a factor therein.

The wording contained herein is duplicated more or less verbatim across several jurisdictions throughout the United States. It applies the Material Element Test, which is somewhat vague and open to interpretation. In his 2012 ruling in the case involving NY poker room owner Lawrence DiCristina, Federal District Judge Jack Weinstein presented compelling evidence for the proposition that poker is a game of skill.

All of this is immaterial, though, to what we're talking about today. DiCristina was charged because he was actually running poker games and taking a small rake for his troubles. There are no laws criminalizing poker for the ordinary players joining such games in NY. There are provisions making promoting gambling against the law, but only someone who “knowingly advances or profits from unlawful gambling activity” would fall into this category:

“Advance gambling activity.” A person “advances gambling activity” when, acting other than as a player [emphasis added], he engages in conduct which materially aids any form of gambling activity.

Other parts of the law make it clear that someone organizing, providing equipment for, and inviting people to a game in which he or she derives no financial gain, except through actual gameplay, is considered just a player for the purposes of these rules. Thus, social home games are unquestionably legally OK.

Some individuals who like to see monsters hiding in every shadow feel that online pokerists are liable to prosecution under 225.30, “Possession of a gambling device.” A computer, the argument goes, could be considered a gambling device if it's used to play cards at unlicensed sites. Well, let's take a look and see what the law really says:

a. A person is guilty of possession of a gambling device when, with knowledge of the character thereof, he or she manufactures, sells, transports, places or possesses, or conducts or negotiates any transaction affecting or designed to affect ownership, custody or use of:
1. A slot machine, unless such possession is permitted pursuant to article nine-A of the general municipal law; or
2. Any other gambling device, believing that the same is to be used in the advancement of unlawful gambling activity; or
3. A coin operated gambling device with intent to use such device in the advancement of unlawful gambling activity.

We can dismiss parts 1 and 3 right away because there's no way a PC is a slot machine or a coin operated gambling device. And the second part only comes into play if the accused acts “believing that the same [the device] is to be used in the advancement of unlawful gambling activity.” We've already seen that advancing gambling activity isn't taking place if someone is acting merely as a player. So these restrictions won't affect you if you just play poker on your machine normally. The State of New York goes after operators, not regular players.

The penalties on the books for illegal gambling firms aren't very severe. These infractions are categorized mostly as misdemeanors or low-level felonies. One reason that some poker sites refuse to operate in New York is that perceived violations of state law can trigger the activation of much more severe federal codes. The events of Black Friday in April 2011 loom large in the minds of gambling operators. Around a dozen people connected with PokerStars, Full Tilt Poker, and Absolute Poker were indicted on various federal gambling-related charges in the Southern District of New York. There were also multi-million dollar civil suits involved.

Nevertheless, some internet poker sites are willing to take the risks involved in catering to the New York market. You'll be able to successfully play cards from the comfort of your own home despite the fact that your options are a bit more limited than in some other states.

New York's Poker History

Hourglass

As one of the original 13 colonies of the United States, New York held a population that was not averse to taking risks whether we're talking about crossing the Atlantic to seek a better life or putting their money down on the turn of a card at the gaming tables. Because it wasn't quite as puritanical as some of its New England brethren to the north, it probably exceeded them in toleration for gambling. As with many New World colonies at this time, lotteries were especially popular as they were seen as an easy way to raise funds for public improvement projects without levying taxes.

Yet after American Independence, New Yorkers moved to halt further lottery sales with a rule in the 1821 state constitution against forming any new lottery organizations. In 1848, those preexisting lotteries that had been grandfathered in under the 1821 constitution were barred from operating as well.

John Morrissey
John Morrissey,
19th Century NY Gambler

While lottery mavens, both legitimate and shady, were thus put out of commission, other types of real money wagering flourished. Saratoga Springs was a vacation spot for those seeking out its supposedly healing waters, but merely sitting in the water all day drove visitors to boredom, so they were inclined toward more stimulating pursuits. Several gaming houses and race tracks opened up, and John Morrissey, leader of the Dead Rabbits gang in 1850s New York City, was lured there to try his fortune as a gambling proprietor. Morrissey opened up the Saratoga Race Course and a casino, which is still running today under the name Canfield Casino and Congress Park. Journalist Herbert Ashbury, in his 1938 work “Sucker's Progress: An Informal History of Gambling in America,” had this to say about Morrissey:

He was an expert Poker player, and in private sessions with his friends was noted for scrupulous fairness. But in his public games he was not so particular; his resorts were operated as skinning houses except when honesty brought greater returns…

In the 1890s, the House with the Bronze Door became famed as THE place to go for luxurious upscale gambling in Gotham. Located on 33rd street in Manhattan, the ornate bronze portal which lent the establishment its name presented a respectable if somewhat ordinary image to unknowing passers-by. Within the rooms of the building, however, one encountered sumptuous décor: velvet carpeting, marble sculptures, oil paintings by the masters, and all the other accoutrements of a tastefully arranged aristocratic mansion. The Bronze Door itself was rumored to have been imported from Venice and cost $20,000 – about half a million dollars today. Clearly, this was not a casino that catered to the average Joe.

In addition to faro, roulette, baccarat, and several other popular house-banked games, it featured rooms to which members could adjourn for private gaming. Poker was one of the pastimes that the well-to-do indulged in away from the prying eyes of the public. The largest pot in these games was reportedly $27,000, which was won by a full house of AAAKK. We can thus gauge the kinds of stakes being played for by comparing this figure to the exorbitant cost of the totemic Bronze Door itself and what that amount is equivalent to today.

New York got a new constitution in 1894, and it banned all types of gambling, so the days of the House with the Bronze Door and other, humbler betting parlors were numbered. The House was shut down by the authorities in 1902. Several successor underground casinos popped up, but none compared with the original either in terms of aesthetic splendor or the level of the action taking place.

Arnold Rothstein
NYC Crime Boss
Arnold Rothstein

Rather than disappearing altogether, gambling businesses found ways around the restrictive laws. This was especially true after Prohibition was passed in 1920. Pioneering NYC bootlegging crime boss Arnold Rothstein, implicated but eventually cleared in baseball's 1919 “Black Sox” scandal, became the big name in illicit gambling parlors, which contributed to his alleged fortune of $10 million in ill-gotten gains. He outmaneuvered the corrupt Tammany Hall political machine to become a major power broker in his own right. It was poker that inadvertently led to his demise. After a multi-day, high-stakes poker game in 1928, Rothstein found himself stuck $320,000. He refused to pay, claiming that the game had been rigged, and was shot dead several weeks later.

Perhaps seeking to curtail the exploits of such criminals, the state amended its constitution in 1939 to legitimize pari-mutuel racetrack betting. Charitable bingo followed in 1957 and educational lotteries in 1966. But there was still no place to go for legal poker in New York.

Underground gin, backgammon, and poker clubs began to appear in the Big Apple. It was in these environments that players such as Stu Ungar, Howard Lederer, and Erik Seidel got their starts. As the years wore on, these establishments became an open secret and hosted cash games at ever-escalating blind levels. One of the sharks in these games was Joel “Bagels” Rosenberg, immortalized in the movie “Rounders” as Joey “Knish.” The most prominent of the clubs was the Mayfair, but it was shut down in the year 2000 during the Giuliani mayoral administration. The remaining unauthorized poker facilities either closed down as well or scaled back their endeavors so as to not attract the attention of law enforcement.

In 1993, tribal gaming came to New York with the creation of Turning Stone Casino in the Oneida Nation. In 2013, commercial casinos were authorized in the state for the first time, and three of them opened their doors a few years later.

The latest gambling craze to hit the Empire State was sports betting, which appeared around the middle of 2019. This was made possible by the Supreme Court ruling in Murphy v. NCAA, which found that the federal prohibition against betting on sports was unconstitutional. As it turns out, NYS laws had nothing against properly licensed sportsbooks, so after a short delay while the Gaming Commission drafted the needed rules for the activity, the first sportsbooks opened for business.

According to state law, though, any sports wagering must take place at one of the duly authorized tribal or commercial casino properties. This means that mobile and online betting are not permitted.

Poker Timeline of New York

Timeline of Gambling in NY

Regulation Chance for Online Poker

File Folder

With a population large enough to support several online sites, pretty liberal attitudes in the New York City area, and a demonstrated willingness to allow many types of authorized gaming, New York seems like a no-brainer for licensed online poker. Since 2014, there have been a number of bills introduced that would formalize an internet poker regulation scheme.

In 2017, online poker licensing bill S03898 was passed by the Senate, but the companion legislation in the Assembly, A05250, only made it past the Codes committee before time ran out in the legislative session. Neither bill made much progress in 2018 either. In the 2019 session, relevant bills appeared in both the Assembly and Senate, but they were shelved without much fanfare.

We appear to be getting closer and closer to success every year, so New York is one of a handful of states that actually seem serious about enabling its citizens to do what they please with their own money online. The fact that brick-and-mortar sportsbooks launched in 2019 indicates that there's still an appetite for expanded real money gaming among NY citizens, which might eventually lead to legal online poker.

Land Based Gambling

Large Building

The five major types of brick-and-mortar gambling are all available in the Empire State. They are tribal casinos, state lotteries, charitable gaming, pari-mutuel racetrack betting, and commercial casinos. One quirk of the way live gambling is set up in NY is that all tribal and commercial casinos are located upstate some distance away from New York City. For the majority of residents in The City That Never Sleeps, a jaunt over to Atlantic City in New Jersey may be more convenient.

Turning Stone in Verona has the largest poker room for New Yorkers with 32 tables. Cash games in No Limit Texas Hold'em, Limit Hold'em, Pot Limit Omaha, and Limit Omaha/8 await you. Dealers stand prepared to spread other forms of poker upon request.

Quite a few of the NY casinos have opened up physical sportsbooks where you can bet on all kinds of athletic contests except those involving NYS collegiate teams. We checked out what the sporting action was like and have reported our findings in our Tioga Downs sportsbook review.

Famous New York Poker Players

Yellow Shooting Star

With a history of poker clubs going back more than a century and a population that exceeds that of almost every other state, it's no wonder that New York has spawned more than its fair share of famous cardsharks.

Perhaps the most remarkable of these Gotham hustlers was the unusual Stu “The Kid” Ungar. His father owned an underground Manhattan gambling establishment, and so it's no surprise that young Stu cottoned to the trade as he was growing up in the '50s and '60s.

First devastating his opponents in gin rummy circles, Ungar eventually had to transition full time to poker because nobody wanted to play gin against him for real money. His success continued, and he won three World Series of Poker Main Events: 1980, 1981, and 1997. Stu also picked up another two WSOP bracelets, one in the 1981 $10K Deuce to Seven Draw event and other in the 1983 $5K Seven Card Stud event.

Unfortunately, Stu Ungar's personal habits marred his poker career. He was fond of splurging on expensive meals and betting on sports where he lost a bundle. As the '80s began, he became addicted to cocaine. Little more than a year after his final World Series championship in 1997, he was found dead in a Las Vegas motel with only $800 on him and no other assets to speak of.

Photo of Vanessa Selbst
Vanessa Selbst

Another New Yorker who made a mark on the game is Brooklynite Vanessa Selbst. While attending Yale as a Fulbright scholar, she picked up poker. First playing in private games with her classmates, she soon graduated to cash games in Foxwoods before heading out to Vegas.

Vanessa has taken home three gold bracelets at the WSOP: the 2008 $1,500 PLO, the 2012 $2,500 10-Game 6-Max, and the 2014 $25,000 Mixed-Max NLHE. However, her largest cashes were in non-WSOP tourneys. She scored around $1.8 million for winning the 2010 €7,750 Partouche Poker Tour Main Event and then picked up approximately $1.4 million for her victory in the 2013 PCA €25,500 High Roller event.

In total, Selbst's live tournament winnings exceed $11 million. For her phenomenal success in multiple variants of poker, many consider her the best female player of all time.

Other prominent New Yorkers in the world of poker include 1988 WSOP ME runner-up Erik Seidel, double bracelet-winner Nick Schulman, Andrew “LuckyChewy” Lichtenberger, and Scott Seiver.

Online Casinos

There are a few land-based casinos that cater to New York residents, but even the most ardent fans of these establishments must sometimes feel like not leaving the house to participate in casino gaming. Therefore, we've created a shortlist of reputable online casinos that allow you to place your bets in the comfort of your own home:

Logo of Ignition Casino

1. Ignition Casino - $1,500 Bonus ($2,000 BTC Bonus)

Bovada Logo
2. Bovada Casino - 100% up to $1,000 Bonus x 3 ($3,750 for Bitcoiners)
SB Casino Logo
3. Sportsbetting Casino - $3,000 Bonuses and Frequent Reloads

There are several other trustworthy internet casinos for you to choose from, and we cover them in our list of top USA-friendly online casinos.

Online Sportsbooks

Following the Supreme Court decision in Murphy v. NCAA, many states rushed to debut sports betting, which is now legal for states to regulate at their discretion. New York is no exception; however, there's an important caveat: Only physical sportsbook facilities are licensed to conduct this activity. So if you want to bet on the game online, you must head over to an honest offshore provider of sports betting services. Fortunately, we've identified several good ones below:

Bovada.lv Logo

1. Bovada Sports - $250 Sports Welcome Bonus ($750 Bonus for BTC)

SB.ag Logo
2. Sportsbetting.ag - $1,000 Bonus and Neverending 25% Reloads
Logo of Nitrogen Sportsbook
3. Nitrogen Sports - Low-juice Bitcoin Bookmaker

For additional information about online sportsbooks for Americans, click here.

Conclusion

There aren't as many alternatives for online poker in New York as there are in some other parts of the country, but you can still play cards over the internet as much as you wish. There are no laws against playing privately for your own recreation and profit. Choose a good New York online poker site, and shuffle up and deal!

Do you have an address in a nearby state?

New York's Neighboring States

If you are lucky enough to have another address in a nearby state, be it your business address, summer home, second apartment, family home, etc, you may have other online poker options available to you. Here are a list of the states that border New York and Professional Rakeback's review on each of them: Pennsylvania, Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Ohio, New Jersey, New HampshireMaryland, and Delaware.

Many New Yorkers are jet setters and travel all over the country and the world. Thus, it would not surprise us if you, as a New Yorker, happen to have a secondary residence outside of the handful of states we just mentioned. But fear not, we have more information for you to gobble up. Take a look at our Online Poker Guide for US players, which has data regarding real money play on all 50 states. From there, you can easily find a poker site to play at, or zoom in and check out the options in any other state of the union.

Unfortunately many players across our country don't realize that they have options to play poker online. If you've found this information helpful, please take a moment to share it with your friends and family and thus help to grow the game that we all love so much.

Frequently Asked Questions

New Yorkers sometimes have questions about the prospect of playing online poker in the state. Look below for a compilation of some of the most common questions and their answers.

+   Are there any state-regulated online poker sites in New York?

+   Is it legal to play internet poker for real money in New York?

+   Is PokerStars legal for New Yorkers?

+   Is Ignition Casino Poker legal in New York?

+   Is BetOnline a legal New York poker room?

+   I see that Global Poker operates in New York, is it legal?

+   What is the minimum age for gambling in New York?

+   Can I organize and run my own online gaming company in New York?

+   How can I make deposits and withdrawals to and from online poker rooms?

+   Do I have to pay taxes on my online poker winnings?

+   Is it possible to play poker on my tablet or phone?

+   Are there any Mac-compatible internet poker sites?

+   Is the underground NYC poker scene any good?

+   What is Wall Street poker?

 

 


We strive to maintain this information and update it frequently with our research. However, we are not immune to making mistakes or omitting information that you, dear reader, may find of use. If you have any further questions not addressed in this guide or have noted any discrepancies or inaccuracies we urge you to contact us with your questions and concerns so that we may swiftly address them!

 

Comments

Are there any sites that don't allow HUD's that a Mac user from NY could play on?

None of the NY-friendly offshore sites necessarily ban the use of HUDs. Those that don't necessarily want HUD users choose simply not to cooperate with the major HUD company that owns Poker Tracker and Holdem Manager. Thus, effectively, most HUD users are shut out.

Some enterprising people found ways to make hand history converters that allow PT4 and HM2 to work on various sites that don't really want them, but it doesn't seem like much of anything is done about this by the sites.

You could play on Ignition, BetOnline / Sportsbetting.ag, any Grand Poker Network skin and they would allow you from NY as well as have Mac software. None of them are "HUD-friendly" though on the first two, there are hand history converters that allow the use of PT4/HM2.

With that said, you might want to rush off to play at Grand Poker. And there is nothing wrong with that. Just know that they are a small poker room where you will likely find no more than half a dozen to a dozen games running at any given time across all stakes and levels.